Rotoscopers
  • News
  • Podcasts
    • Animation Addicts Podcast
    • Every Episode Ever
  • Reviews
    • Animated Movies
    • Art Books
    • Blu-ray/DVD
    • Live Action
  • Interviews
  • Opinions
  • Studios
    • Aardman
    • Blue Sky Studios
    • Disney
    • Don Bluth
    • DreamWorks
    • Fox Animation Studios
    • Illumination Entertainment
    • LAIKA
    • Lucasfilm Animation
    • Paramount Animation
    • Pixar
    • Sony Pictures Animation
    • Reel FX
    • Studio Ghibli
    • Warner Animation
  • Animation Calendar
No Result
View All Result
Rotoscopers
  • News
  • Podcasts
    • Animation Addicts Podcast
    • Every Episode Ever
  • Reviews
    • Animated Movies
    • Art Books
    • Blu-ray/DVD
    • Live Action
  • Interviews
  • Opinions
  • Studios
    • Aardman
    • Blue Sky Studios
    • Disney
    • Don Bluth
    • DreamWorks
    • Fox Animation Studios
    • Illumination Entertainment
    • LAIKA
    • Lucasfilm Animation
    • Paramount Animation
    • Pixar
    • Sony Pictures Animation
    • Reel FX
    • Studio Ghibli
    • Warner Animation
  • Animation Calendar
No Result
View All Result
Rotoscopers
No Result
View All Result
Home Studios Disney

[REVIEW] ‘Aladdin’ 2019: Shining, Shimmering, Soulless.

Gary Wright by Gary Wright
May 26, 2019
in Disney, Live Action, Live Action, Reviews, Rotoscopers, The Latest Animation News
5 min read
13
[REVIEW] ‘Aladdin’ 2019: Shining, Shimmering, Soulless.
145
SHARES
2.9k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Another year, another big budget Disney live action adaptation. Surprisingly (or not) Aladdin is actually the second of FIVE live action adaptations of Disney animated properties releasing in 2019 alone. Dumbo released a couple of months ago, with The Lion King due in July, a Maleficent sequel in October, and Lady and the Tramp due for Disney+ later this Fall. To Disney’s credit, they’ve had much success with their remakes in recent years – look no further than 2016’s delightful The Jungle Book and 2017’s lavish Beauty and the Beast. With Aladdin, arguably the most magical of all Disney animated classics, not to mention one of the most beloved and critically acclaimed, the remake bubble seems to have finally burst. This new Aladdin may look dazzling on the surface, but lacks the very elements that made the original so universally beloved: a heart and soul.

Aladdin-Live-Action-Teaser-Trailer

The very opening Arabian Nights sequence (with lyrics even more drastically altered) assumes that everyone watching is already familiar with the story of the 1992 film, so major story elements (Jasmine running away, the Cave of Wonders) are treated as a montage. We’re five minutes in and Aladdin and Jasmine are running from the law. Even newcomer Mena Massoud’s million dollar smile can’t fix the pacing issues evident so early on. The film recreates the major story beats of the original, but learns from mistakes of past remakes and adds in a few new story elements. Jafar (Marwan Kenzari) now has a tragic backstory and a deeper motivation for seeking the mythical lamp, but that doesn’t stop him from being almost the blandest character in the entire film. Gone is the sinister, menacingly evil Jafar, and here is eye-candy Jafar who can’t be bothered to modify his monotone. Nothing against the actor, but a script this bland (“Bring me the lamp” is yawn-worthy here) does him no favors. It’s a similar case for Massoud, who tries his level best to be roguishly endearing but can’t do much with the poor writing. No wonder he gets his own dance sequence.

Naomi Scott, however, turns out to be the saving grace the film desperately needs. Princess Jasmine this time around is trying to prove she has what it takes to be sultan, but tradition would have her stay silent and on the sidelines. This is where Scott absolutely kills it as Jasmine. While her new solo song “Speechless” is no “Evermore” – rather a pop-rock ballad that sounds like a Jessie J reject – Scott absolutely brings new life to Jasmine. She lends Jasmine a sense of wonder, determination and angst in the perfect ratio. This just might be her career-defining role. Also delightful is Nasim Pedrad as Jasmine’s handmaiden Dalia. Every scene Pedrad is in is hilarious, her dry wit and sarcastic charm being a true scene stealer.

Jasmine from Aladdin

I wish I could say the same about the original scene stealer. Will Smith does his best as the Genie. It just falls flat. Director Guy Ritchie tries admirably to give Genie a sense of elasticity and shape-shifting antics much like the animated film, but it just doesn’t work in this medium. CGI Genie seems laughably dull, a far cry from the beloved role brought to life by the incomparable Robin Williams in 1992. This is not meant to be a comparison of the two, and for the most part, 2019 Genie is pretty much its own thing, but the script (again, that script) forces Will Smith to recall moments that are too close to the 1992 Genie. And while Smith adds his own flavour to the Genie, it just isn’t that endearing. This Genie also has none of the compassion and tenderness that we know and love. In Will Smith’s defense, the scenes where he’s in his human form are a lot of fun. His own love story is amusingly cute, and reminds us that actual Will Smith works a million times better than CGI Will Smith. If only his ad-libs didn’t seem so forced.

Supporting characters like Abu and Iago fail to bring anything interesting to the table. Abu is just a CGI monkey who acts like a real monkey and is hard to get fond of. Iago (voiced by Alan Tudyk) hardly talks aside from during a few key moments supposed to be sinister, but are mostly embarrassingly obvious. We know he’s a streetrat, Iago. Rajah the tiger’s design is incredibly well done, and the few scenes he’s in (usually alongside Jasmine) are extremely effective and serve the purpose well. Finally, the Sultan (Navid Negahban) is possibly the blandest, dullest character of the lot. Not that he doesn’t have much to do, but he seems too upset and heartbroken most of the time for us to support him. While his paternal qualities do shine through, he’s a far cry from the endearing, bumbling Sultan of the original film.

Most importantly, and possibly the weakest link here, is the music. Guy Ritchie might be known for directing Madonna music videos, but maybe Disney’s best bet would have been someone who knows the art of film musicals. While Massoud, Scott and Smith’s vocals range from passable (Massoud) to soaring (Scott), the musical sequences seem incredibly disjointed, low on energy and downright frustrating. The 1992 Aladdin is a classic because of its music and this remakes does a poor job honoring that legacy. The “Prince Ali” scene feels flat and uninspired, while the magic carpet ride seems much smaller in scope this time around (“Where are the pyramids?” someone at my screening yelled). “A Whole New World” turns into a tour of Agrabah. Not to mention the lack of emotional payoff, because Jasmine wants to see THE WORLD, not just Agrabah. And, worst of all, there is no “Prince Ali” reprise, that deliciously evil song Jafar sang in the original. It’s so hard to separate these songs from the 1992 version, because the emotional impact they had back then are hard to replicate here.

Aladdin Magic Carpet

Where the film gets it right, though, is the visual flair. Agrabah looks stunning, as do the incredible Afghan-inspired costumes that also have a Bollywood influence. That influence also seeps through in a fun dance number where Aladdin tries to impress Jasmine. It’s genius in its presentation. And while there are plenty of CGI misfires (Jafar in the climax), there are more hits than misses (the magic carpet looks lovely). This is a lavish film, indeed.

But all the visual splendor can’t help a film that lacks true depth and an emotional connection. The instances where the film stretches its story too thin are painfully obvious. This is essentially a very expensive interpretation of the 1992 film, with enough to please fans of the original and just enough new elements to bump up its run time. Of course it will be a box office juggernaut, of course there will be more remakes down the line, but when the magic dust settles, we will only remember the films that truly bring out our emotions, that touch us, lift us up, and make us cry or laugh or sing along.

This Aladdin is not one of those films.

★★

 

Edited by: Kajsa Rain Forden

Tags: aladdinlive action
Previous Post

Adventure Awaits in DreamWorks/Pearl’s ‘Abominable’ Trailer

Next Post

Don Hahn’s Howard Ashman Doc to Debut on ‘Major New Streaming Service’… Hint, Hint

Gary Wright

Gary Wright

Gary is a Disney nerd whose favorite animated movies are Beauty and the Beast, The Incredibles and Frozen. When he's not out catching Pokemon or watching animated films, he's usually analyzing literature or creating artwork.

Related Posts

Animation Addicts Podcast #240: Review of ‘Disney Princess – The Concert’
Animation Addicts Podcast

Animation Addicts Podcast #240: Review of ‘Disney Princess – The Concert’

February 23, 2022
‘Disney Princess – The Concert’ Review: One More Reason to Have Your Tiara Ready
Disney

‘Disney Princess – The Concert’ Review: One More Reason to Have Your Tiara Ready

February 17, 2022
Animation Addicts Podcast #239: Rotoscopers 10-year Spectacular
Animation Addicts Podcast

Animation Addicts Podcast #239: Rotoscopers 10-year Spectacular

February 15, 2022
Don Bluth to Release Autobiography in Summer 2022
Don Bluth

Don Bluth to Release Autobiography in Summer 2022

February 9, 2022
Load More
Next Post
Howard-Ashman

Don Hahn's Howard Ashman Doc to Debut on 'Major New Streaming Service'... Hint, Hint

Discussion about this post

Popular Posts

  • ‘Disney Princess – The Concert’ Review: One More Reason to Have Your Tiara Ready 178 views
  • Don Bluth to Release Autobiography in Summer 2022 70 views
  • Animation Addicts Podcast #240: Review of ‘Disney Princess – The Concert’ 66 views
  • Animation Addicts Podcast #239: Rotoscopers 10-year Spectacular 65 views
  • Animation Addicts Podcast #238: ‘We Don’t Talk About Bruno’ Hits #1 on the Billboard Hot 100 52 views
  • 11k Fans
  • 12.1k Followers
  • 5.7k Followers
  • 5.3k Followers

Recently Added

Animation Addicts Podcast #240: Review of ‘Disney Princess – The Concert’

Animation Addicts Podcast #240: Review of ‘Disney Princess – The Concert’

February 23, 2022
‘Disney Princess – The Concert’ Review: One More Reason to Have Your Tiara Ready

‘Disney Princess – The Concert’ Review: One More Reason to Have Your Tiara Ready

February 17, 2022
Animation Addicts Podcast #239: Rotoscopers 10-year Spectacular

Animation Addicts Podcast #239: Rotoscopers 10-year Spectacular

February 15, 2022
Animation Addicts Podcast #238: ‘We Don’t Talk About Bruno’ Hits #1 on the Billboard Hot 100

Animation Addicts Podcast #238: ‘We Don’t Talk About Bruno’ Hits #1 on the Billboard Hot 100

February 9, 2022
Don Bluth to Release Autobiography in Summer 2022

Don Bluth to Release Autobiography in Summer 2022

February 9, 2022
Rotoscopers

© 2019 Rotoscopers

Important Links

  • About
  • Support
  • Contact
  • Store
  • Privacy Policy
  • User Posts

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Podcasts
    • Animation Addicts Podcast
    • Every Episode Ever
  • Reviews
    • Animated Movies
    • Art Books
    • Blu-ray/DVD
    • Live Action
  • Interviews
  • Opinions
  • Studios
    • Aardman
    • Blue Sky Studios
    • Disney
    • Don Bluth
    • DreamWorks
    • Fox Animation Studios
    • Illumination Entertainment
    • LAIKA
    • Lucasfilm Animation
    • Paramount Animation
    • Pixar
    • Sony Pictures Animation
    • Reel FX
    • Studio Ghibli
    • Warner Animation
  • Animation Calendar

© 2019 Rotoscopers

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
Posting....