Rotoscopers
  • News
  • Podcasts
    • Animation Addicts Podcast
    • Every Episode Ever
  • Reviews
    • Animated Movies
    • Art Books
    • Blu-ray/DVD
    • Live Action
  • Interviews
  • Opinions
  • Studios
    • Aardman
    • Blue Sky Studios
    • Disney
    • Don Bluth
    • DreamWorks
    • Fox Animation Studios
    • Illumination Entertainment
    • LAIKA
    • Lucasfilm Animation
    • Paramount Animation
    • Pixar
    • Sony Pictures Animation
    • Reel FX
    • Studio Ghibli
    • Warner Animation
  • Animation Calendar
No Result
View All Result
Rotoscopers
  • News
  • Podcasts
    • Animation Addicts Podcast
    • Every Episode Ever
  • Reviews
    • Animated Movies
    • Art Books
    • Blu-ray/DVD
    • Live Action
  • Interviews
  • Opinions
  • Studios
    • Aardman
    • Blue Sky Studios
    • Disney
    • Don Bluth
    • DreamWorks
    • Fox Animation Studios
    • Illumination Entertainment
    • LAIKA
    • Lucasfilm Animation
    • Paramount Animation
    • Pixar
    • Sony Pictures Animation
    • Reel FX
    • Studio Ghibli
    • Warner Animation
  • Animation Calendar
No Result
View All Result
Rotoscopers
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinions

Cinematographers in Animation: Has the Time Come?

Brandon Smith by Brandon Smith
February 12, 2015
in Opinions
5 min read
0
Cinematographers in Animation: Has the Time Come?
6.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

index29

Introduction

Whenever we think about the technical side of animation, the focus is almost always on subjects such as renders, rigging, textures, details, and so on. But we don’t tend to focus as much on an area that is often considered a vital part of live-action filmmaking: cinematography.

Why is that?

Could it be that it just isn’t brought up because of our ingrained expectation that animation is a different medium from live-action? Perhaps. That fact is certainly true in most cases. Animation is a medium with a set of rules that is different from the demands of live-action photography.

But as the tools and technology of animation evolve with each passing year, is it not fair to say that animation might have reached a point where we can now start to treat the ‘camera’ with the same amount of weight and importance that is regularly afforded to the actual animation process?

I personally think so. And according to an article on Animation Magazine that covered the subject, it is a sentiment that’s starting to gather steam in the animation industry.

Breakthrough

In a fascinating editorial piece titled ‘The Evolving Role of the CG Director of Photography’, we are indeed given many examples of how the role of the cinematographer in animation is just now beginning to achieve credibility – and why it might be time for a title such as ‘CG Director of Cinematography’.

The article first covers a milestone achieved last year by Pixar’s Sharon Calahan: she became the first cinematographer who’s work consisted solely of CG Animated features to join the American Society of Cinematographers. Calahan has worked with Pixar ever since A Bug’s Life in 1998 and is one of the few cinematographers who work in animation with that title. She is currently working on The Good Dinosaur.

Jim Morris, President of Pixar and one of Calahan’s biggest supporters, made a point of how rare this recognition is: “It’s weird that it’s not widely recognized.”

He continues this line of thought by making an apt comparison to stop-motion: “Because the fact is — to use the stop-motion analogy, where you’re lighting puppets and miniature sets — in CG, you’re doing the same thing in virtual space. Over time, we found people who were like-minded, and believed that computer graphics was just another arm of cinematography. It’s just another set of tools to create imagery.”

He goes on to describe how Calahan faced “a Spanish Inquisition of 20 or 25 DPs grilling her. She does her own lighting studies, and she brought samples of how she breaks down a scene. She knocked ’em dead.”

Different Approaches

Nowadays, every animation studio approaches the Director of Photography position in their own way. To put it simply: some have it, some don’t.

Animal Logic enlisted the expertise of Pablo Plaisted, a former animator who worked on Happy Feet, for The LEGO Movie, but the responsibility was shared with lighting supervisor Craig Welsh. Blue Sky Studios has Renato Falcao, who’s DP credits include Epic, the Rio movies, and this year’s Peanuts adaptation. Disney and DreamWorks have no such credits on either of their films – you get the usual job descriptors of layout and lighting supervisors – but DreamWorks has enlisted the help of renowned DP Roger Deakins for films such as Rise of the Guardians and the How to Train Your Dragon films. At Pixar, the DP credit is also shared between the ‘camera’ operator and the lighting supervisor.

When describing how Pixar came to accept the value of a DP, Calahan added, “In the early days, Pixar was a lot like Disney is now. Our first model was what we knew: cel animation. That was how we started on Toy Story. But through the process of learning how to make movies, we realized that our process was more akin to how somebody might make a live-action film. So we thought, why don’t we start thinking about it more that way instead of trying to compare it to cel animation, which is a very different working method. A lot depends on where a company — and its talent — is coming from.”

The Case for Cinematographers in Animation

Despite the scarcity of people in this position, it is nonetheless a job that will hopefully, given the rapid advancement in the technology and tools, be embraced by more studios across the industry in earnest. In fact, it may just be the evolution of the technology, and the involved nature of the process, that could make CG animation become more attractive to cinematographers with backgrounds in live action.

“The process is becoming more collaborative as the tools become more facile,” says Calahan. “I can be involved earlier in the process. Lighting can affect story and layout and sets and the art department much more than before. And I can do things to support the upstream departments by doing pre-lighting, so they can see what the intent of a scene is going to be. We also talk more as a group. There are fewer barriers to doing that because the tools aren’t in the way anymore. Our mental process has been slowly, gradually, becoming more and more like live action, where everybody is working together at the same time.”

Falcao also made a good case for the importance of the position, stating, “The rules of cinematography totally apply to animated movies. For cutting, you need an establishing shot, a medium shot, and a close-up. Sometimes the storyboards will break those rules, which is totally fine. But DPs have to make sure that the viewer doesn’t feel lost — especially in an action sequence.”

The article ends with Plaisted adding a final thought, once again pointing to the evolution of the medium: “I put a huge emphasis on the ‘rules’ of classical cinema, but I do think we are obliged to push forward the CG animation medium. For me, the rules are worth breaking whenever story, context and maybe even innovation demand it.”

The Importance of Having a ‘CG Director of Photography’

If animation is slowly (but surely) to be recognized as a viable medium in its own right, then I see no reason why we shouldn’t add ‘CG Director of Photography’ as a job descriptor. They bring to animation the eye of someone who’s been on a set and behind an actual camera, and therefore bringing a level of depth and perspective that previously wouldn’t have been associated with animation otherwise.

If it is one of the many ways that animation can be seen on par with live-action, then I wholly support it.

What do you think? Any argument for, or against, having cinematographers in animation? 

Edited by: Kajsa Rain Forden

Tags: Ani-MatographyPablo PlaistedRenato FalcaoSharon Calahan
Previous Post

‘Kingsman: The Secret Service’ Gets Stop-Motion Trailer

Next Post

Animation Addicts 87: The Secret of NIMH – Too Many “J” Names

Brandon Smith

Brandon Smith

Brandon is your average nerd with a love for nerdy things (games, comics, anime/manga, etc.). He also loves reading and writing and plans to be an author someday. For now, he writes with passion and curiosity about the world of animation. He lives with his family in North Carolina and is currently attending college.

Related Posts

Animation Addicts Podcast #247: Ranking the Best Disney Sidekick Songs
Animation Addicts Podcast

Animation Addicts Podcast #247: Ranking the Best Disney Sidekick Songs

April 19, 2022
[OPINION] 10 Heartwarming Animated Adverts to Watch This Holiday Season
Coronavirus

[OPINION] 10 Heartwarming Animated Adverts to Watch This Holiday Season

December 17, 2021
Animation Addicts Podcast #226: The Tim Burton Theory
Animation Addicts Podcast

Animation Addicts Podcast #226: The Tim Burton Theory

October 26, 2021
Animation Addicts Podcast #225: Disney Animated Movie Musical Opening Songs Ranked
Animation Addicts Podcast

Animation Addicts Podcast #225: Disney Animated Movie Musical Opening Songs Ranked

October 19, 2021
Load More
Next Post
87-secret-of-nimh-animation-addicts-podcast-website-art

Animation Addicts 87: The Secret of NIMH - Too Many "J" Names

Discussion about this post

Popular Posts

  • [REVIEW] ‘Minions: The Rise of Gru’ – If It Ain’t Broke… Just Add More? 97 views
  • Animation Addicts Podcast #257: Looking Back At The Disney Afternoon 78 views
  • Animation Addicts Podcast #254: Swan Princess 9 Kingdom of Music – This Ain’t Your Momma’s Swan Princess 41 views
  • Animation Addicts Podcast #255: Swan Princess 10: A Royal Wedding – What Else Is There? 26 views
  • Animation Addicts Podcast #256 Alice In Wonderland – Know Your Drugs 21 views
  • 11k Fans
  • 12k Followers
  • 5.8k Followers
  • 5.3k Followers

Recently Added

[REVIEW] ‘Minions: The Rise of Gru’ – If It Ain’t Broke… Just Add More?

[REVIEW] ‘Minions: The Rise of Gru’ – If It Ain’t Broke… Just Add More?

July 1, 2022
Animation Addicts Podcast #257: Looking Back At The Disney Afternoon

Animation Addicts Podcast #257: Looking Back At The Disney Afternoon

June 28, 2022
Animation Addicts Podcast #256 Alice In Wonderland – Know Your Drugs

Animation Addicts Podcast #256 Alice In Wonderland – Know Your Drugs

June 21, 2022
Animation Addicts Podcast #255: Swan Princess 10: A Royal Wedding – What Else Is There?

Animation Addicts Podcast #255: Swan Princess 10: A Royal Wedding – What Else Is There?

June 14, 2022
Animation Addicts Podcast #254: Swan Princess 9 Kingdom of Music – This Ain’t Your Momma’s Swan Princess

Animation Addicts Podcast #254: Swan Princess 9 Kingdom of Music – This Ain’t Your Momma’s Swan Princess

June 7, 2022
Rotoscopers

© 2019 Rotoscopers

Important Links

  • About
  • Support
  • Contact
  • Store
  • Privacy Policy
  • User Posts

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Podcasts
    • Animation Addicts Podcast
    • Every Episode Ever
  • Reviews
    • Animated Movies
    • Art Books
    • Blu-ray/DVD
    • Live Action
  • Interviews
  • Opinions
  • Studios
    • Aardman
    • Blue Sky Studios
    • Disney
    • Don Bluth
    • DreamWorks
    • Fox Animation Studios
    • Illumination Entertainment
    • LAIKA
    • Lucasfilm Animation
    • Paramount Animation
    • Pixar
    • Sony Pictures Animation
    • Reel FX
    • Studio Ghibli
    • Warner Animation
  • Animation Calendar

© 2019 Rotoscopers

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
Posting....